By John Horty
During this brief monograph, John Horty explores the problems awarded for Gottlob Frege's semantic idea, in addition to its sleek descendents, by means of the therapy of outlined expressions. The ebook starts by way of targeting the mental constraints governing Frege's proposal of feel, or which means, and argues that, given those constraints, even the remedy of easy stipulative definitions led Frege to special problems. Horty is ready to recommend methods out of those problems which are either philosophically and logically believable and Fregean in spirit. This dialogue is then attached to a couple of extra commonplace issues, resembling indexicality and the dialogue of strategies in fresh theories of brain and language. within the latter a part of the booklet, after introducing an easy semantic version of senses as approaches, Horty considers the issues that definitions current for Frege's concept that the feel of an expression may still reflect its grammatical constitution. The requirement should be happy, he argues, provided that outlined expressions--and incomplete expressions as well--are assigned senses in their personal, instead of handled contextually. He then explores a method during which those senses will be reified in the procedural version, drawing on principles from paintings within the semantics of laptop programming languages. With its mix of technical semantics and background of philosophy, Horty's publication tackles the various toughest questions within the philosophy of language. it may curiosity philosophers, logicians, and linguists.
Read or Download Frege on Definitions: A Case Study of Semantic Content PDF
Similar semantics books
This paintings provides a unified conception of element inside of common Grammar. It offers an strange blend of syntactic, semantic, and pragmatic ways to a unmarried area, and offers specific linguistic analyses of 5 languages with very various aspectual platforms: English, French, Mandarin chinese language, Navajo and Russian.
During this brief monograph, John Horty explores the problems offered for Gottlob Frege's semantic idea, in addition to its smooth descendents, by means of the therapy of outlined expressions. The ebook starts by way of targeting the mental constraints governing Frege's thought of feel, or which means, and argues that, given those constraints, even the remedy of straightforward stipulative definitions led Frege to big problems.
Linguistic research of the discussion of Italian cinema, utilizing techniques and methodologies from pragmatics, dialog research and discourse research.
- Pragmatics and Grammar (Cambridge Textbooks in Linguistics)
- Multimodality and Genre: A Foundation for the Systematic Analysis of Multimodal Documents
- The Syntax and Semantics of Discourse Markers
- Dynamics of Meaning: Anaphora, Presupposition, and the Theory of Grammar
Extra resources for Frege on Definitions: A Case Study of Semantic Content
On the view hinted at in these passages, then, only statements exhibiting this form could be classified as uninformative, or self-evident. It would take a special act 10 Prege describes another kind of case in which we mistake rapid calculation for immediate insight in the Grundlagen. Speaking of mathematical inferences that appear obvious, though they do not exhibit the form of simple logical inferences, he writes: "A single such step is really a whole compendium, equivalent to several simple inferences .
It is important, then, to maintain this sharp distinction between stipulative and explicative definitions, but as long as we are able to maintain the distinction in our minds, there is no particular point in trying to enforce it with our notation. As a matter of convenience, it is often easier to act as if we were stipulating directly the meanings of the expressions we wish to explicate. Suppose, as a second example, that we are engaged in the project of "reconstructing" arithmetic within some standard set theory, with epsilon as its only non-logical primitive.
Each of these examples involves expressions drawn from natural language, and in Frege's eyes, natural languages were terribly defective instruments: even apart from their vagueness and ambiguity, he believed they were incapable of expressing thoughts in a manner suitable for a precise specification of their inferential relations. In his preface to the Begriffsschrift, Frege explains how frustration with the flaws he saw in natural languages led him to develop his alternative formalism, writing that, in attempting to codify these inferential relations: I found the inadequacy of language to be an obstacle; no matter how unwieldy the expressions I was ready to accept, I was less and less able ...